Three questions that decide it
1. Is your roof hipped or gabled?
Stand in the garden and look at the side of the roof. If it slopes in, it's hipped and a hip to gable is likely. If the side wall goes straight up to a point, it's a gable, and a rear dormer may be all you need.
2. How much head height is there?
Measure from the top of a ceiling joist to the underside of the ridge. About 2.2 metres or more opens up every option, including a simple rooflight conversion. Less than that usually means a dormer.
3. Is your house in a protected area?
In a conservation area or the Surrey Hills National Landscape, dormers and hip to gables need planning permission and design matters more. Rooflights are often still possible. Check your address before choosing.
Loft type questions
What is the most popular type of loft conversion in Guildford?
Rear dormers and hip to gable conversions, because so much of Guildford's housing is terraces and interwar semis. Rooflight conversions are popular in conservation areas.
Which loft conversion adds the most space?
A mansard, followed by a hip to gable with a rear dormer. A rooflight conversion adds the least usable floor area because the walls still follow the roof slope.
Can I combine different types?
Yes. Hip to gable with a rear dormer is a combination, and many conversions add rooflights to the front slope with a dormer at the rear.